2015 Stock Picking Contest

[klid]

I am afraid you haven't Klid, or if you have, the message is no longer getting through to the score sheet? My result for 2015 dropped from around 10% to around 6% (from end of 31st December to end of January 4th, a period of no trading) after you made your adjustments for dividends not included over the last two months. That can't be right.
SNOOPY

Whoops. Thank you - the dividends were all there but not included in calculation. Updated rankings:

Rank	Alias	Stocks	Change
1	Big Friendly Moose	PAY PEB TIL DIL OGC	89.67%
2	in4abuck	ATM AWF NWF SCL SUM	86.83%
3	flugenbear	WDT ATM NWF BLT RAK	78.01%
4	dodgy	NZR ATM CNU MFT RBD	72.96%
5	golden city	PEB THL TNR TIL NZR	70.38%
6	wolf	ATM SUM FPH HNZ DIL	69.46%
7	PointyHat	HNZ SKL ATM XRO NPX	68.25%
8	airedale	SPK DIL ATM MOA HNZ	67.32%
9	Chopper	XRO HNZ MET RYM TIL	66.32%
10	maccas321	DIL ATM FPH XRO AIR	66.10%
11	axe	SCL RYM ZEL KMD ATM	65.28%
12	minimoke	AIR CVT RBD SCL TEN	62.92%
13	Harvey Specter	VML BLT SEA PAY NWF	60.94%
14	Parrot	AIR ATM IFT RBD HNZ	60.62%
15	flying	CNU SML PEB BLT ATM	60.26%
16	hoyinma	HNZ PGW ATM FPH DIL	59.50%
17	Fisherking	DIL AIA ATM XRO WYN	58.68%
18	xerof	XRO SUM PEB ATM AIR	55.86%
19	PartyPooper	ATM SUM RYM HNZ WHS	55.68%
20	cool bear	ARG ATM HNZ PGW VML	54.74%
21	ras	AIR IFT HNZ ATM MRP	54.54%
22	Sylvor	SLI OGC ATM PEB NWF	53.62%
23	NZSilver	HNZ ATM SUM SKC PEB	53.34%
24	McGinty	ATM HLG SCL SCY VIL	53.29%
25	waikare	ATM FPH HBY PGW RYM	53.20%
26	Crystal Ball	DIL PEB ATM SUM HNZ	52.75%
27	Rego55	AIR ATM OGC HNZ BRL	51.97%
28	Kirk	ATM THL DIL IFT KMD	51.21%
29	black knat	TNR ATM EVO RAK EBO	50.34%
30	gv1	SUM XRO ATM PEB NZX	49.95%
31	iceman	ATM DIL HNZ PGW ANZ	49.33%
32	Ginger_steps_	XRO ATM PEB VML WDT	48.89%
33	hummerh40	BLT HNZ PEB ATM BRL	47.81%
34	Everwood	ATM BFW DIL WYN XRO	46.87%
35	ABhatnagar	DIL HNZ PAY RYM SUM	46.67%
36	janner	HNZ TNR ATM WYN PGW	45.65%
37	garfy	ATM HNZ PEB PGW THL	45.52%
38	Fred114	STU ATM GMT KPG MRP	45.50%
39	fiasco	HNZ ATM WYN PEB AIR	43.83%
40	amalgam	HNZ ATM CAV STU TNR	43.70%
41	shandynz	ATM CRP MRP SUM CNU	43.18%
42	LegendOfRiot	DIL XRO PEB WYN ATM	43.04%
43	scor066	PEB SLI ATM SUM DIL	42.38%
44	PHuljich	PAY DIL RYM FPH MFT	42.26%
45	zs_cecil	ATM HNZ PEB RAK XRO	42.20%
46	silu	ATM IFT MET SKO CGF	40.21%
47	hairofthedog	PEB DIL ATM HNZ STU	39.71%
48	bobbles	ATM PEB WYN PGW HNZ	38.39%
49	kizame	ATM TNR HNZ PPL CAV	37.91%
50	Bobcat.	VML OGC NWF BRL BLT	37.46%
51	couta1	XRO DIL PEB SLI ATM	37.16%
52	see weed	ATM BRM MLN PGW TTK	36.96%
53	DarkHorse	AWF CVT SCL THL VIL	35.12%
54	grunta	PEB HNZ ATM FBU STU	35.04%
55	mattwanz	ATM NZO PEB XRO CGF	32.16%
56	Blocker3	DIL PAY RYM SUM VIL	31.59%
57	EAGLE	SUM SEA ATM OHE BRL	30.97%
58	pedro.nz	MFT AIA BLT XRO HNZ	30.24%
59	shonen knife	TTK HBY SEA HLG ATM	29.87%
60	Dogs of the NZX	ATM XRO KMD NZO PEB	29.57%
61	First NZ Capital	DIL MFT SCL TPW ZEL	29.49%
61	LPearce	AIA BRL CRP HNZ ATM	29.41%
62	KiwiGekko	AIR CNU HNZ RBD THL	29.27%
63	Guild	HNZ AIR BLT PGW THL	29.10%
64	CodeRed	MHI SUM SKL DIL NZR	27.71%
65	Psychic	PEB CRP RBC BLT ATM	27.64%
66	glennj	EBO NPX MFT AWF THL	27.55%
67	bull....	DIL RBD TNR NZR VHP	27.29%
68	NOCASH	AIR HNZ RBD FBU BLT	27.21%
69	percy	SCL TNR EBO HNZ PGW	26.90%
70	Joshuatree	HNZ OGC SEK SCL PGW	26.85%
71	JK	PAY OHE SUM DIL PEB	26.28%
72	Vaygor1	GXH RYM NZR POT CDI	26.20%
73	alistair85	DIL AIR WYN SUM FPH	26.05%
74	spmcg	MFT AIA HNZ FPH THL	25.94%
75	budda sticks	SLI IFT PAY RYM PGW	25.69%
76	JBWere	FSF IFT DIL NPX	25.43%
76	hillbillybob	AIA AIR DIL FPH MET	25.21%
77	Toulouse - Luzern	AIA FPH IFT MFT THL	25.19%
78	Heke	AIA AIR HNZ FPH MFT	25.16%
79	aspar13	CNU FPH RYM IFT SKC	25.12%
80	stanace	SUM WDT NZO SKC BLT	24.69%
81	kerryo	BLT TNR SUM AIA PEB	24.09%
82	Awesome	TEN WYN SUM THL FBU	24.02%
83	TSR	RBD BGR SCL IFT PGW	23.37%
84	resol	THL GXH MRP CNU IFT	23.25%
85	Jantar	HNZ IFT NWF GNE CEN	23.24%
86	grimy	WHS BLT STU NPX MET	23.17%
87	markymarknz	ATM DIL CRP PEB MCK	23.02%
88	Rabbi	FPH EBO RYM RBD MRP	22.61%
89	clips	EBO AIA NZO HNZ FPH	22.56%
90	Pricey	AIR VGL FPH IFT KMD	22.29%
91	greater fool	ANZ SCL SPK THL TWR	21.85%
92	Dilli	PEB AIA CNU HNZ EBO	21.75%
93	d.viviani	RBD IFT FBU FPH AWK	21.23%
94	Incognito	CMO DGL GXH RBD SPN	21.10%
95	mikeybycrikey	AIR IFT VML XRO HLG	20.94%
96	Deej5	SUM HNZ MHI AIA PFI	20.90%
97	Roger	AIR HNZ MFT FPH DIL	20.55%
98	Yoda	MFT SUM DIL BLT SLI	20.49%
99	Microsloth	AIA FPH RYM MFT HNZ	20.23%
100	Corporate	DIL XRO MOA SNK AIR	20.04%
101	wiifm	XRO MRP SKC CNU POT	19.80%
102	finwatcher	RBD XRO POT WBC AIR	19.59%
103	mickey2	EBO HNZ MPG POT THL	19.53%
104	Schrodinger	XRO NZR SKO VML NZX	19.16%
105	gmatt	ATM CRP TNR TTK VML	19.01%
106	MSL Capital	AIA DIL MRP VML HNZ	18.85%
106	Major von Tempsky	SPK DIL MFT AIA AIR	18.59%
107	forest	PEB AIR SAN TEN THL	18.56%
108	Roadrunner	DIL OGC PEB NPX HNZ	18.47%
109	kombi	VIL RBD CNU PGW SCL	18.14%
110	Aaron	OGC VCT CNU MRP PGW	18.13%
111	pierre	BLT DIL PEB HNZ XRO	18.12%
112	clarky	XRO SUM DIL BGR ABA	18.09%
113	elzorro	CAV CNU FRE MFT OGC	17.31%
114	shasta	IFT AIR RBC SCL WHS	17.20%
115	dagoldtoof	FPH HNZ EBO PEB HLG	16.86%
116	stones	TNR FPH FRE HNZ IFT	16.68%
117	Diplodocus	PGW HNZ RAK THL CNU	16.48%
118	bunter	PGW SCL GNE HBY TNR	16.38%
119	mask	DIL AIA IFT OGC STU	16.37%
120	noodles	VIL CVT IQE PGW SCL	16.27%
121	nzspeak	AIR PGW GNE RBC NPX	16.21%
122	Sideshow Bob	AIR HNZ GNE OGC PGW	15.96%
123	Bobdn	WHS SPK GNE TME CNU	15.49%
124	Macquarie Securities	AIR AIA IQE RBD VGL	15.30%
124	Paint it Black	AIR AIA SKC THL PEB	15.20%
125	GTM3442	BLT CGF TNR HNZ SML	15.13%
126	newtrader	IFT TME MFT HNZ AIR	14.74%
127	Slowlearna	NPX DIL AIR MRP SLI	14.39%
128	cyclist	BRL GNE SUM HNZ OGC	14.03%
129	RRR	POT MFT SCL MRP SKT	13.34%
130	gypsy	PEB HNZ SUM AIA SML	12.97%
131	dingonz	GNE HNZ OHE VGL THL	12.40%
132	BlackPeter	BRL NWF SKL PEB OGC	12.35%
133	huxley	GNE IFT SUM KMD POT	12.04%
134	RobbieS	AIR BRL IFT TEN EVO	11.87%
135	ScrappyO	HNZ IFT NZX VHP GNE	11.82%
136	Snoopy	PGW SCT SKC SPK RBD	11.80%
137	RGR367	RAK NPX XRO SKO PGW	11.73%
138	Lou	NPT CMO THL HNZ TWR	11.54%
139	johndes	CNU HNZ SPK IFT NZO	11.34%
140	Jay	AIA DIL HNZ XRO PEB	11.27%
141	hcpp88	ANZ MFT WHS SUM XRO	10.93%
142	toucan22	ATM BGR CRP NZO PEB	10.87%
143	bonnie vie	WYN PEB KMD BLT SUM	10.77%
144	smithy	GNE IFT HNZ SEA PLE	10.39%
145	MPC	HNZ SKO SML SUM MVN	10.23%
146	modandm	AIR TME TWR IFT NZX	10.15%
147	Commander	MFT FPH FRE RYM FBU	9.85%
148	KJ	BGR HLG HNZ STU THL	9.81%
149	sum1else	SPY SLI XRO HLG SCL	9.34%
150	Abacus	FSF STU HNZ AIR DIL	9.32%
151	kanaka	BLT CNU CRP SML XRO	9.10%
152	bilbo	BLT SEA VML SLI DIL	8.88%
153	silverblizzard888	SLI VML FFW THL XRO	8.66%
154	Southern_Belle	XRO PEB DIL HNZ AIR	8.61%
155	brutus	WYN XRO OHE DIL VGL	8.01%
156	Hamilton Hindin Green	CNU EBO MET SLI STU	7.87%
156	Paper Tiger	ANZ MFT POT WBC XRO	7.62%
157	000831	PEB HLG DIL SUM WYN	7.56%
158	Flogs	DIL HNZ PEB SUM WYN	7.48%
159	warthog	HBY NPX TME WYN OHE	7.42%
160	val	HBY SCL PGW HLG VIL	6.93%
161	OOH	GNE PEB OGC HNZ DIL	6.46%
162	stoploss	AWF DIL MFT RYM TME	6.34%
163	hmm	SUM TNR OHE SKC SCY	6.18%
164	whirly	ABA MCK POT RYM TUR	6.04%
165	SCOTTY	HNZ IFT PGW SCY WHS	5.94%
166	Forsyth Barr	IFT MFT RYM SKC TWR	5.73%
166	tim23	XRO TWR BRL DIL AIR	5.56%
167	kaybee	RAK BFW ERD MOA VML	5.47%
168	zigzag	HBY SKL ABA AWF DIL	5.33%
169	tenzing	SKL RYM BGR DIL WYN	5.28%
170	Baaarney	HNZ RYM MFT MRP SPK	5.08%
171	Ruaboy	HNZ TNR MET SKL SML	5.04%
172	casino	SUM OHE PEB AIA SKC	4.75%
173	blockhead	AIR BRL SPK HNZ RYM	4.69%
174	Radler	PEB WHS AIA PCT GTK	4.48%
175	Craigs Inv Partners	FPH CEN FBU MFT MET	4.44%
175	ekman	EBO DIL NZO RBC WDT	4.33%
176	jimmi	DIL AIR PEB XRO FBU	3.85%
177	bohemian	AIR FPH MFT WYN OHE	3.83%
178	Hawkeye	XRO THL HLG PEB STU	2.90%
179	junh	TNR ANZ HNZ WBC TWR	2.61%
180	OMF	ABA DIL ERD FPH MHI	2.50%
180	foodie	BFW CGF VML HNZ PGW	2.14%
181	Lizard	HNZ OIC PGW TEN VIL	0.60%
182	lissica	FBU RYM IFT TWR MFT	0.47%
183	JayRiggs	SUM KMD MHI NZX OIC	0.38%
184	lancewiggs	XRO ZEL MRP SPY SLI	0.00%
185	Scooter	ABA SEA MFT WYN AIA	-0.52%
186	777	CAV HNZ DIL PEB CMO	-1.13%
187	bung5	PGW TTK CNU GNE WHS	-1.46%
188	The Grinch	CAV DIL TNR HNZ PEB	-1.63%
189	ari	AIA FPH RBC SEA SNK	-1.65%
190	Mista_Trix	PEB WYN XRO DIL OIC	-2.75%
191	sun	CNU OHE NZO HNZ SML	-2.96%
192	evski	AIA CMO MFT VIL WYN	-5.21%
193	Bosse	EBO RBC NZO SNK WDT	-5.98%
194	sgt pepper	TNR HNZ TWR CRP TEN	-6.42%
195	jackson.cropp	BRL PEB SUM XRO NZO	-6.68%
196	whitewatergeo	SPK CRP GNE THL RYM	-8.85%
197	BaaBaa	SLI FIN XRO PEB VML	-10.63%
198	BigBob	NZO PEB IFT GNE NZX	-10.66%
199	evander	DIL PEB MFT SLI PGW	-11.96%
200	klid	HNZ IQE OGC RAK ERD	-13.94%
201	barleeni	BRL CRP AIR NZR PEB	-14.12%
202	Latama	CRP HNZ PEB SUM WYN	-15.09%
203	exactchange	CRP IFT XRO SLI GPG	-15.61%
204	Acegolfer	HNZ PGW DIL VIL TTK	-15.77%
205	minerbarejet	PEB PPL WDT BRL XRO	-16.14%
206	snapiti	RAK BRL CRP PEB SCL	-20.40%
207	Okebw	VIL HNZ HBY CRP OGC	-21.71%
208	biker	BRL CRP TNR PEB RBC	-38.40%

[Snoopy]

Whoops. Thank you - the dividends were all there but not included in calculation. Updated rankings:

Thanks for the correction Klid, plus all your hard work over the year. Very much appreciated.

One competitor you didn't mention was dear old NZX50. The accumulation index looks to have gone from 5603 on 05/01/2015 to 6324 on 31/12/2015. I make that a gain of 12.89%. So my own result of 11.80% (*) was a fraction below par. However, that was pretty much expected because my value strategy does slightly underperform the index when stock market conditions are good. I more than make up for that in bad years. So here's to a horrible 2016 ;-)!

SNOOPY

Also I did do a little better than 11.80% anyway due to reducing my average buy price of PGW by 4c over the year, plus making a bit via the SCT rights issue - both issues not reflected in the competition results. So probably nudging that even 12% for the year. Pretty respectable for a boring income generating portfolio.

[Snoopy]

Whoops. Thank you - the dividends were all there but not included in calculation. Updated rankings:

Maybe one more thing has slipped through? Some competitors are shown as DPC holders. But DPC morphed into TNR during the year.

SNOOPY

[klid]

Maybe one more thing has slipped through? Some competitors are shown as DPC holders. But DPC morphed into TNR during the year.

SNOOPY

Yup, thanks again. I changed the 18 picks in 2015 from DPC to TNR and updated TNR with start 32c end 30c and dividends in the year of 1.2c to give total of -2.50%
I actually had done that on 25 Sept but this morning I accidently reverted everything to Feb 2015 which has caused a bit of hassle! (I still need to put back about 100 entries for 2016!)
And KIP to KPG (one pick).