PDA

View Full Version : Broker recommendations please - large one off transaction



Yossarian
30-05-2019, 06:32 PM
Hi all
I was looking for recommendations.
My situation is that I have recently inherited a portfolio of NZ and AU holdings, both shares and bonds, in the order of $670k. I would like to sell these holdings in the near future.
What is the most cost effective way of doing this? I have had a couple of quotes from full service brokers which are both 1% commission. Is there a way of disposing of these shares for less commission? I don't really want to pay $6700 for what seems a fairly simple job.
I'm aware there are online brokers who offer much lower commissions however that may be complicated by two facts (1) the shares are still held in the name of the estate, rather than my name directly (can an estate open an online account?) and (2) I live in the UK. So I'm not sure if I'd be eligible for an online account.
Any advice appreciated. I guess I can just ask for a better rate from the full service broker - does anyone know if they are prepared to negotiate?
Many thanks
Y

777
30-05-2019, 07:38 PM
There is this option from Direct Brokerage which you could investigate

https://www.directbroking.co.nz/DirectTrade/static/oneoffsell.aspx

I have just realised they want 1.25% but still worth asking.

kiora
30-05-2019, 09:15 PM
Hi all
I was looking for recommendations.
My situation is that I have recently inherited a portfolio of NZ and AU holdings, both shares and bonds, in the order of $670k. I would like to sell these holdings in the near future.
What is the most cost effective way of doing this? I have had a couple of quotes from full service brokers which are both 1% commission. Is there a way of disposing of these shares for less commission? I don't really want to pay $6700 for what seems a fairly simple job.
I'm aware there are online brokers who offer much lower commissions however that may be complicated by two facts (1) the shares are still held in the name of the estate, rather than my name directly (can an estate open an online account?) and (2) I live in the UK. So I'm not sure if I'd be eligible for an online account.
Any advice appreciated. I guess I can just ask for a better rate from the full service broker - does anyone know if they are prepared to negotiate?
Many thanksY

Try contacting Computershare in the first instance to see what you need to do.Most company shares are registered with them.They can sell shares for you as well
https://www-au.computershare.com/Investor/help/printableforms?cc=NZ
If you would like to sell shares you already hold, you can use Investor Trade, Computershare's online share sale facility for issuer sponsored securityholdings. The service is available to investors in companies where Computershare acts as share registrar.
– Each batch order sale will entail a transaction fee of $15 plus $0.12 per share* sold. – Each market order sale will entail a transaction fee of $25 plus $0.12 per share* sold. – Fees are deducted from the proceeds derived from the sale.
https://www-au.computershare.com/Investor/Contact/?cc=NZ&lang=en

blackcap
31-05-2019, 01:24 AM
Each batch order sale will entail a transaction fee of $15 plus $0.12 per share* sold. Each market order sale will entail a transaction fee of $25 plus $0.12 per share* sold. Fees are deducted from the proceeds derived from the sale.
https://www-au.computershare.com/Investor/Contact/?cc=NZ&lang=en

Wow that is usury, especially if you have shares that are valued at the lower end. So you sell say 10,000 PEB shares at 20 cents. Order value is $2,000. Fee's are $25 plus $1,200 or a total of $1,225. Seems rather bizarre and ludicrous.

Crazy or have I read your post incorrectly?

Yossarian
31-05-2019, 05:19 AM
Thanks for the replies. Yep I agree that pricing seems way off, unless you are selling Mainfreight shares or something...

SBQ
31-05-2019, 11:48 AM
Hi all
I was looking for recommendations.
My situation is that I have recently inherited a portfolio of NZ and AU holdings, both shares and bonds, in the order of $670k. I would like to sell these holdings in the near future.
What is the most cost effective way of doing this? I have had a couple of quotes from full service brokers which are both 1% commission. Is there a way of disposing of these shares for less commission? I don't really want to pay $6700 for what seems a fairly simple job.
I'm aware there are online brokers who offer much lower commissions however that may be complicated by two facts (1) the shares are still held in the name of the estate, rather than my name directly (can an estate open an online account?) and (2) I live in the UK. So I'm not sure if I'd be eligible for an online account.
Any advice appreciated. I guess I can just ask for a better rate from the full service broker - does anyone know if they are prepared to negotiate?
Many thanks
Y

Are the share & bond certificates held in 'street form' ? In this day of age no one ever holds shares or bonds physically as it's slow and a great hassle to remit to the broker when the decision to sell is made. Furthermore holding them in street form is a bit like holding physical gold in that you need to go to an exchange or broker to sell. Did a brokerage account original exist for which the certificates were physically issued? If so, during the estate probate process, you should of had access to the brokerage account and thus can remit the certificates back to the broker; for which the broker can change the names and thus ownership of the shares and bonds. This is an important process in disbursing the assets in the estate. Anotherwords, presenting certificates in someone else's name to a broker by opening up a new account requires a lot of proof (done again, through the estate probate process). Doing so after the estate has dissolved is an illegal act.

For the hassles, it would seem paying the 1% is a small price to pay for the complication. Personally I would never hold assets under 1 name and practice the JWROS (joint tenancy).

stoploss
31-05-2019, 12:21 PM
I think you will find ( I did ) if you have shares that are in Australia that you will have to get probate over them via a lawyer ... ( cost 1000/1600 ish )
A broker should be negotiable for a one off trade or liquidation of a portfolio . If you don't have any luck PM me I will put you in contact with one that would help

Cheers

S/L

Yossarian
01-06-2019, 06:05 PM
Many thanks for the replies. One broker has offered an effective rate just under 0.5% so we'll go with that I think.
No physical share certificates as far as I am aware, these holdings were mostly bought in the last 5 years or so.
Re probate in Australia, I was originally advised we would need that however it seems that we may now get away without it. Not sure why to be honest!

Jonboyz
08-06-2019, 09:24 AM
Many thanks for the replies. One broker has offered an effective rate just under 0.5% so we'll go with that I think.
No physical share certificates as far as I am aware, these holdings were mostly bought in the last 5 years or so.
Re probate in Australia, I was originally advised we would need that however it seems that we may now get away without it. Not sure why to be honest!

Out of interest, which broker?

Joshuatree
08-06-2019, 11:10 AM
Brokers are often quite negotiable for larger $ holdings, One just has to ask them whats the best deal you can give me?

Yossarian
08-06-2019, 05:13 PM
Craigs.
Cheers Joshua, that was what I did.