Valuecruncher.com

[fish]

http://www.valuecruncher.com/

Looks an interesting site to find valuations

[whirly]

Thanks for the link Fish. Thats really interesting. Im going to have to do some analysis of one company to see if It holds any value for me. Couldnt find a blank template anywhere which would be nice to be able to enter own values for companies not listed into.

Does anyone already use a similar spreadsheet type setup for this. Ive never done any FA beyond basic overviews so would be interesting to crunch some numbers.

[BlackPeter]

Hi folks,

I came recently across valuecruncher.com and was looking for some views on their methodology and the quality of the underlying values they calculate

From a guts feeling (looking at some of their NZX valuations) does the overall recommendation they come up with frequently makes sense, however not sure, whether I can say that as well about the "implied value" they publish?

Some random examples ... (my view in brackets)

ANZ - BUY (yes), but implied value $64.08?
IFT - BUY (hmm, probably o.k.), but implied value $18.31?
OGC - BUY (probably sensible), implied value $2.03 (could be right)
PGW - BUY (might be sensible), implied value 0.78 (not impossible)
RAK - BUY (who would want to do that?) and implied value $1.22 ???
TEM - SELL (not sure), but implied value £0.96 ???
WHS - BUY (yeah, they probably have some more life in them), but implied value $22.15 (sounds out of wack)?

Any information or views on this tool?

Anybody here who subscribed to value cruncher? If yes - what do you get (on top of the free service) for this subscription and is it worth it?

Any comments appreciated,
Thanks & regards,

BlackPeter

discl: hold all of above but RAK;

[BIRMANBOY]

Surely you jest??!! LOL ..the values look like they have been pulled from a xmas cracker.
http://www.valuecruncher.com/

Looks an interesting site to find valuations

[TimmyTP]

Surely you jest??!! LOL ..the values look like they have been pulled from a xmas cracker.
The Ryman valuation is my favourite.

Anyway check the small print in the website footer:
© Commerce Commission 2013 in association with Morningstar


[not really]

[BlackPeter]

O.K. - maybe this explains a thing or two:

http://blog.valuecruncher.com/

Valuecruncher data feeds
August 28th, 2013
Please note that we have turned off the Valuecruncher data feeds. This means that the data on the Valuecruncher website is no longer up to date. Please be aware of this.

Please also note – we have not taken any money from subscribers over the last 18 months. If subscribers have provided financial information – it is secure and no money will be taken from credit cards by Valuecruncher.

Regards,

Mark Clare

Valuecruncher CEO