http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/6348...r-meanspirited
Just Water offer 'mean-spirited'
TIM HUNTER
Last updated 16:39, November 24 2014
Share
'MEAN': A takeover offer for the water cooler company could shortchange minority shareholders, a broker says.
'MEAN': A takeover offer for the water cooler company could shortchange minority shareholders, a broker says.
Sharebroker Colin Giffney has described a takeover offer for NZX-listed Just Water International as "mean and mean-spirited", saying it undervalues the company.
Just Water, which provides water coolers for offices, is subject to a 15c a share takeover bid from interests associated with its founder Tony Falkenstein.
The unconditional offer values Just Water at $14m and falls at the low end of a valuation from KordaMentha of 14.7c to 16.8c a share.
Since making the offer on November 14, Falkenstein's bid vehicle Harvard has moved from 71 to 73 per cent ownership, but has run into opposition from some minority shareholders.
This afternoon Just Water shares changed hands at 16c, indicating some investors think the price could go higher.
Giffney, whose firm Giffney and Jones was lead manager of Just Water's float in May 2004, said he had wanted to mail his thoughts on the offer to other shareholders, but had been denied access to an electronic version of the share register.
"I didn't want to go to the media, I wanted to go to shareholders, but they're forcing me basically."
Valuation could only ever be a matter of opinion, he said.
"All I'm doing is trying to communicate an alternative view. I'm not saying mine's right."
Giffney said in his view Just Water had good cashflow and in the last four years had repaid $13 million of debt, with borrowings falling from $26m in June 2010 to $13.1m in June 2014.
Ad Feedback
"At moment you've got companies floating that haven't made a dollar and haven't done anything, selling on multiples to earnings.
"This one shareholders are being asked to give up at 4.4 times [earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation]. I'm sorry there's a disconnect somewhere."
He said the offer was "mean and mean-spirited to loyal shareholders who have supported the company through the tough times."
Giffney said because the offer was unconditional, which meant all purchases through the takeover were final, shareholders should not accept until it was clear what the large shareholders are doing.
"I'm pretty disgusted with the way they're behaving."
Falkenstein could not be reached for comment this afternoon.
Bookmarks