-
Also aussie will be bringing capital requirements for banks... their decision might come out end of the week.
-
Why did you buy in the first place Manni99 ??
Genuine question ..
-
ANZ performance in NZ
I have been looking at the operating performance of ANZ in the New Zealand marketplace. It makes an interesting yardstick with that local bank Heartland.
The problem with comparisons is that banks to not report their performance in an identical way. My particular measuring stick of choice at the moment is 'Operating Margin'. This is 'Operating Profit' divided by assets under management. I regard 'Operating Profit' as the same as Earnings Before Interest and Tax (EBIT).
If you turn to page 156 of AR2013, the 'Segment Result Before Tax' (EBT) for NZ operations is listed at $A1,219m. ( I will work in $A for the NZ operation because this is the currency used in in the Annual Report.) To get EBIT I have to add back an allowance for the core underlying bank debt.
Total interest expense is shown in note 4 as $15,869m. But this includes interest payable to depositors. The underlying interest bill is only $4,789m.
Where the allocation of corporate interest between segments is not specified, I prefer to allocate this in proportion to divisional revenue. Again using the information on page 156, New Zealand revenue is:
$2,208m / $18,446m = 12% of the total.
12% of $4,789m comes out to $574m
Adding this to the NZ segment result gives me my EBIT figure.
$1,219m + $579m = $1,793m
Total NZ 'external assets' are listed on p156 as $85,229m.
So the 'operating margin' based on assets in loans is:
$1,793m / $85,229m = 2.104%
I note that this is the operating margin, looking at the NZ business in its entireity.
SNOOPY
Last edited by Snoopy; 09-01-2014 at 05:40 PM.
Watch out for the most persistent and dangerous version of Covid-19: B.S.24/7
-
Originally Posted by Snoopy
I have been looking at the operating performance of ANZ in the New Zealand marketplace. It makes an interesting yardstick with that local bank Heartland.
My EBIT figure.
$1,219m + $579m = $1,793m
Total NZ 'external assets' are listed on p156 as $85,229m.
So the 'operating margin' based on assets in loans is:
$1,793m / $85,229m = 2.104%
I note that this is the operating margin, looking at the NZ business in its entirety.
For operating segment purposes, Heartland operates in four sectors:
1/ Retail & Consumer
2/ Business
3/ Rural
4/ Non core property
ANZ have more categories in their breakdown of business units. I cannot say whether the ANZ categories, listed in AR2013 p127 dovetail neatly into the rather broader Heartland headings. But my best guess as to how they might be aligned is below:
1/ Retail & Consumer includes 'Personal Lending'
2/ Business includes 'Business Services', ''Electricity Gas and Water supply', 'Entertainment Leisure and Tourism', 'Financial Investment and Insurance', 'Government & Official Institutions', 'Manufacturing', 'Retail Trade', 'Transport and Storage', 'Wholesale Trade' 'Other' and 'Financial Investment and Insurance'.
3/ Rural includes 'Agriculture forestry fishing and mining'
4/ Non core property includes 'Construction' and 'Property Services'
So how do the relative numbers stack up? Stay tuned.
SNOOPY
Watch out for the most persistent and dangerous version of Covid-19: B.S.24/7
-
Work from the best source of data
Snoopy: If you want to analyse the NZ part of ANZ why not work from the Disclosure Statements available at http://anz.co.nz/about-us/media-cent...r-information/
If you are going to burrow into any other NZ banks they should have public DS as well.
Best Wishes
Paper Tiger
Last edited by Snow Leopard; 09-01-2014 at 06:11 PM.
Reason: to 'be' or not to 'be'
om mani peme hum
-
An interesting exercise, Snoopy, but not particularly helpful if your object is to compare the investment merits of the two banks. Whether you buy ANZ on the NZX or the ASX you're buying ANZ Group, the NZ business of which forms a minor - and decreasing - portion of revenue and profits. On the other hand, comparisons of the respective NZ businesses may offer some helpful insights into HNZ's prospects, providing that it's possible to take reasonable regard for the different business segments, sizes etc.
Cheers
-
I am reminded of a friend of mine who used Macquaries research.Every three or four months they had a "new" "our preferred"
bank.!! My friend's advisor told him to take no notice as the one he held {ANZ] would be "our preferred" bank again some time soon.
ANZ is offcourse looking to Asia to drive growth.All four Australian banks have proved to be excellent investments.Although HNZ's model is a lot different , it will be interesting to see whether they can grow
[from a small base] as well as, or out preform the Aussie banks.
Update.My new advisor at Craig's rates ANZ as his preferred Australian bank.[at present]lol.
Last edited by percy; 10-01-2014 at 09:34 AM.
-
I find these useful. KPMG has pulled the NZ components for you already..
http://www.kpmg.com/NZ/en/IssuesAndI...-June-2013.pdf
-
Member
I still hold ANZ,WBC and NAB but on the ASX Options. Im still long and I still believe we are just on a corrective phase right now and these big four are jockeying for position in the Aussie mortgage market since their real estate prices are picking up as well and RBA might not be thinking of raising rates as of yet. But aside from these big 4 banks dont forget MQG Macquarie since they might also surprise us with a strong boost in Share Price.
-
Originally Posted by macduffy
An interesting exercise, Snoopy, but not particularly helpful if your object is to compare the investment merits of the two banks. Whether you buy ANZ on the NZX or the ASX you're buying ANZ Group, the NZ business of which forms a minor - and decreasing - portion of revenue and profits.
Macduffy, you are quite right to point out that looking at the investment performance of ANZ in NZ is not that useful from an ANZ investor perspective. I do know this but didn't state it explicitly which I probably should have done.
You aren't right about ANZ NZ being a decreasing area of profits for the whole group though. In FY2013,the profit (NPAT) contributed from NZ was $A881m out of a total profit of $6,272m. That represents 14% of total profits (AR2013 p156). Do the same exercise for FY2012 and the $A642m in profit from the $5,661m total represents only 11% of total profits. Looking into 2014 I can see the buoyant NZ economy,the rollover of the integration of the National bank and the rise in the $NZ/$A exchange rate providing a further big boost in earnings in $A terms. So contrary to what you suggest, NZ is actually the fastest growing profit (and revenue) region within the ANZ group and is getting more and more significant overall.
On the other hand, comparisons of the respective NZ businesses may offer some helpful insights into HNZ's prospects, providing that it's possible to take reasonable regard for the different business segments, sizes etc.
As you surmise this is the real reason for looking at the NZ section of ANZ in particular. But your point on making sure the sector by sector comparisons are valid is very relevant.
SNOOPY
Watch out for the most persistent and dangerous version of Covid-19: B.S.24/7
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|
|
Bookmarks