Competition Challenge TO MACDUNK

[STRAT]

STRAT, Where is your pride man SHREWDY likened you to an old woman and asked you to make a judgement. The MACDUNKS would never stand for that sort of thing JEEZE STRAT i will back you up to the hilt if you demand an appology. I do expect you to fiddle the numbers a bit to make up for your mistake. Dont let the SHREWD one take advantage of you. Macdunk

LOL.
Macca I would never fiddle the numbers, Im a strait up kinda fella. Ive been called way worse things than Judge Judy and I suspect you have also.

No comment on the verdict? I take it from that all parties are satisfied

[duncan macgregor]

STRAT, Can you give us an update at the end of the month please i want to see if SHREwDY has scratched back to the starting line. He has one that more than halved its price and another that is still a long way to go to double its price. Meantimes Macdunks resource selections are steaming ahead with the only snag being his granny selection.Macdunk

[Crypto Crude]

Mackdunk,
Why wait until the end of the month for an update?
heres one right now...

Shrewd crude- positive 14.4%
Mackdunk- negative 9.5%
Strat- negative 10.3%
...
Mackdunk, YOUR recent loses on NWE cancel out returns you made from PRC...

.^sc

[tim23]

Excellent, well done being positive in this market

[STRAT]

STRAT, Can you give us an update at the end of the month please i want to see if SHREwDY has scratched back to the starting line. He has one that more than halved its price and another that is still a long way to go to double its price. Meantimes Macdunks resource selections are steaming ahead with the only snag being his granny selection.Macdunk

Sorry Macca,
Been a bit busy.

How we gonna work this out? At the risk of starting a new debate this is how I see it. We all started with two stocks with a 50/50 equity in each. You had to sell down AGM ( at a profit ) and used that money to buy PRC which means in order for me to to show your overall performance I need some numbers. Sell price AGM. Buy price PRC. I can then work out the ratio betwen your two stocks and your overall performance to date.

[duncan macgregor]

Sorry Macca,
Been a bit busy.

How we gonna work this out? At the risk of starting a new debate this is how I see it. We all started with two stocks with a 50/50 equity in each. You had to sell down AGM ( at a profit ) and used that money to buy PRC which means in order for me to to show your overall performance I need some numbers. Sell price AGM. Buy price PRC. I can then work out the ratio betwen your two stocks and your overall performance to date.

STRAT you dont do it like that. You work out the percentage profit on AGM which gets added to the profit or loss on PRC. You cant take it in a situation like that and say you sold AGM at a profit then bought PRC with the profits. You are miles out with the numbers the Shrewd one is in negative territory. Your old mate KEEPINYAHONEST. Macdunk

[duncan macgregor]

STRUTH I have just looked up the prices and SHREWDY is in front. Imagine tailgating that guy for GAWDS SAKE.
1, SHREWDY , FML bought at 10c now 4.3c = - 57% What a bum pick.
VPE bought at 16c now 28c = +75% Lucky pick
2, Macdunk, AGM bought at 73.5c sold at 110c delisted +34% than bought
PRC bought at 208c now 233c = +12%
NWE bought at 26.5c now 15c = - 43% Shrewdies granny selection
3,STRAT, MHL bought at 3.3c now 1.8c = - 45% as bad as it gets.
AMU bought at 67.5c now 58c = -14%
There you go strat did a rough count it looks like Shrewdy and i are in positive territory which in this market is not to bad at all. Macdunk

[duncan macgregor]

Sorry Macca,
Been a bit busy.

How we gonna work this out? At the risk of starting a new debate this is how I see it. We all started with two stocks with a 50/50 equity in each. You had to sell down AGM ( at a profit ) and used that money to buy PRC which means in order for me to to show your overall performance I need some numbers. Sell price AGM. Buy price PRC. I can then work out the ratio betwen your two stocks and your overall performance to date.

SHREWDY i am only giving you the numbers according to STRATS ruling.
AGM .735c according to you delisted at 110c = 36.5c gain = 49.65
prc 208c according to you now 238c = 30c gain = 14.42% = total of 64.07% less whatever your stupid NWE cost me. However in the real world when AGM got delisted all the funds would have gone on the next company which is only fair and reasonable giving me a higher return of 71.24% which STRAT in his wisdom will come back at you and tell you how wrong you are. Macdunk

[Crypto Crude]

What do you mean by, from strats ruling... he has not made one yet...
....
From that it looks like we are both in agreement,
But....
because AGM is 50% of the portfolio, you divide it by 2, or multiply it by .5
so... 49.65/2=24.83% increase...
add in PRC from 2.08 to 2.38 =.3/2.08= 14.4/2= 7.21% add them up...
32.04%...
NWE 26.5 to 15.5 --> minus 41.51%/2= -20.75%

OR.....+49.65%, +14.4% minus 41.51%= 22.54%/2= 11.27%....
somewhere you have to divide by 2... I will leave it up to start....

32.04% less 20.75%= 11.29%.... hum... your slowly increasing your lead mackdunk...
Is this correct Strat...?

.^sc

[Crypto Crude]

mackdunk,
OK dude.. I made up a bunch of numbers to see what sort of reaction id get...
I will work all the numbers through...

shrewd crude-
fml- 10c to 4.3c ... Down 57%/2= minus 28.5
vpe- 16c to 28c.... plus 75% /2=plus 37.5
total plus 9%...

Mackdunk...
agm (inside job)- 73.5c to $1.10= plus 49.66/2=plus 24.83%
nwe- 26,5c (hahaha) to 15c= minus 43.40/2= minus 21.7%
prc nzx (sad tale)... $2.08 to $2.33= plus 12.01%/2 = plus 6%...
add all those up...
plus 9.13%...

Strat...
amu- 67.5 to 58= minus14.07%/2 = minus 7.04%
mhl- 3.3 to 1.8= minus 45.45%/2= minus 22.73%
add those up....
minus 29.77%


.^sc