Views on the Moderation on this Forum (started by STMOD)

[blackcap]

Bloody hell! really banned for the banter between Roger and PT?? What is this site coming to? They were both expressing different opinions and that is what makes these sites so valuable to the investors and potential investors. If we all agreed with each other... well no point in coming at all.

[mickey2]

I have always enjoyed the thoughts of Roger and Paper Tiger on various threads - and learned from them. Sometimes it's good to face the challenge of reconciling opposing points of view! Hope to see them both back soon!
Disc: Hold HNZ

[LAC]

Bloody hell! really banned for the banter between Roger and PT?? What is this site coming to? They were both expressing different opinions and that is what makes these sites so valuable to the investors and potential investors. If we all agreed with each other... well no point in coming at all.

I was actually enjoying the opposing views....maybe the moderators can let us know which posts got them banned?
How long are they banned for? They were quite active members too

[pierre]

I was actually enjoying the opposing views....maybe the moderators can let us know which posts got them banned?
How long are they banned for? They were quite active members too

I have no problem with posters having opposing views, but what does become incredibly tiresome is the endless repetition of the message. I enjoy most of the contributions from Roger and PT but I'm also enjoying a day or two's respite from Roger's constant bagging of HNZ (and the constant pumping of AIR).

Discl: Hold both (HNZ and AIR that is - not Roger and PT!)

[kizame]

And I have been banned for saying what i think of the moderators,I still hold that same view,If you can't have some lively debate on here why have a forum.
I actually don't agree with Roger but that shouldn't stop him from being able to freely express his views,and PT is a great contributor,enjoy all his posts.
Come on moderators,get with the times,free speech and all that,nobody has been abused.

[percy]

I have no problem with posters having opposing views, but what does become incredibly tiresome is the endless repetition of the message. I enjoy most of the contributions from Roger and PT but I'm also enjoying a day or two's respite from Roger's constant bagging of HNZ (and the constant pumping of AIR).

Discl: Hold both (HNZ and AIR that is - not Roger and PT!)

I think that is what is at the heart of the matter.
Why bother posting ,why bother doing research,why bother trying to have a sensible adult conversation?
Unfortunately more people just can't be bothered.
People having an argument on ST may be entertaining,but those who are trying to make a contributuion end up saying "I can't be bothered".
To those who enjoy a good argument,get off the fence and try and make a useful contribution.Be bothered.

[janner]

I think that is what is at the heart of the matter.
Why bother posting ,why bother doing research,why bother trying to have a sensible adult conversation?
Unfortunately more people just can't be bothered.
People having an argument on ST may be entertaining,but those who are trying to make a contributuion end up saying "I can't be bothered".
To those who enjoy a good argument,get off the fence and try and make a useful contribution.Be bothered.

One has to be charitable..

Share Trader Forum...

Can be addictive :-)))

[janner]

It must also be presented..

Share forum is the best value that is available to so many for so little..

THE BEST !!..

[Joshuatree]

I have no problem with posters having opposing views, but what does become incredibly tiresome is the endless repetition of the message. I enjoy most of the contributions from Roger and PT but I'm also enjoying a day or two's respite from Roger's constant bagging of HNZ (and the constant pumping of AIR).

Discl: Hold both (HNZ and AIRthat is - not Roger and PT!)

I agree with this; who needs the constant multiple posting, spruiking or bagging a stock.Its like he needs to influence and be the authority go to leader and it goes on and on.And encouraging people to buy is potentially sus.Whats the motive here?.If he could come back and share his v good research without the repetition or agenda and higher righteous ground; then welcome ; that would be a win/win for all;if he is not prepared to adjust ; adapt ,well maybe he would be better off with his own blogg site where he can totally suit himself and lead..

[winner69]

I agree with this; who needs the constant multiple posting, spruiking or bagging a stock.Its like he needs to influence and be the authority go to leader and it goes on and on.And encouraging people to buy is potentially sus.Whats the motive here?.If he could come back and share his v good research without the repetition or agenda and higher righteous ground; then welcome ; that would be a win/win for all;if he is not prepared to adjust ; adapt ,well maybe he would be better off with his own blogg site where he can totallying a bit respective suit himself and lead..

Aren't you yourself getting a bit repetitive here doing much the same as you accuse others off doing.

Just an observation - and jeez I am not even a STMOD